Volume 6 Issue 7 - September 15, 2009
Supreme Court judgement out on Right to Motherhood of mentally retarded
D.N.I.S. News Network, India: In July, by way of an interim order, the Supreme Court of India upheld the right to motherhood of a mentally retarded girl who was raped at a government run shelter. The detailed judgement has now been released.
D.N.I.S. had earlier reported about the case which made headlines in July and had forced the judiciary and the country to sit up and take notice of the State’s apathy towards people with mental disabilities. Not only did the State fail to protect the girl, it also tried to terminate the pregnancy against her wishes. It was only because of determined efforts of a young lawyer, Tanu Bedi and support from the disability sector that justice was finally delivered.
The judgement states that there were mainly two considerations behind the final order. The first consideration was the fact that the Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act (M.T.P.) clearly mentions that consent of the woman is an essential condition for abortion, if the woman is an adult and does not have any mental illness. In this case, the woman in question was against the termination. The bench did not agree with the fact that that the High Court had blurred the difference between mental illness and mental retardation to support its decision for termination. It went on to say that the Court cannot disregard a mentally retarded person’s personal autonomy to exercise their reproductive rights.
The second consideration was that even if it was assumed that she was not in a position to make an informed decision, termination was not in her best interest as she was already in her 19th week of pregnancy.
However, the society at large still has not woken up to recognise the sexual and reproductive rights of people with mental retardation. There was plenty of outrage at the Supreme Court's decision. Many questioned whether courts were the place to decide such moral and ethical cases. They also speculated about the future of the child. The National Trust for the Welfare of Persons with Autism, Cerebral Palsy, Mental Retardation and Mental Disabilities has offered to take care of the girl and her baby. They have offered to put her in an independent home, either in Bangalore or closer to Chandigarh.
“The biggest obstacle that a disabled person faces is not the disability but society’s perception towards it,” said Bedi.
“In fact when this case made headlines, everybody was talking about retardation, disability and abortion but no one even bothered about what the girl wanted,” she added.
Recently, when Tinku Ray, a journalist from B.B.C. went to meet the girl, who now stays in a different government shelter home in Chandigarh, she appeared to be looking forward to her baby due in December.Click here for full text of Supreme Court’s judgement (Word - 101 KB)
Click here for B.B.C.’s story
DNIS is produced and managed by:
National Centre for Promotion of Employment for Disabled People
Screening Guidelines to be followed by CISF Security Staff for Passengers with Disabilities at Indian Airports
Rights of Persons with Disabilities Bill
Mental Health Care Bill
CRPD Monitoring Report
20 Stories of Change(book)
- List of Awardees 2015 :NCPEDP MPHASIS Universal Design Awards (2.7 MB)
- List of Awardees 2014 :NCPEDP MPHASIS Universal Design Awards (1 MB)
- List of Awardees 2013 :NCPEDP MPHASIS Universal Design Awards (1.44 MB)
- List of Awardees 2012 :NCPEDP MPHASIS Universal Design Awards (804 KB)
- List of Awardees 2011 :NCPEDP MPHASIS Universal Design Awards (864 KB)
- List of Awardees 2010 :NCPEDP MPHASIS Universal Design Awards (623 KB)
SHELL HELEN KELLER AWARDS
NCPEDP-Shell Helen Keller Awardees 2013
- We practice what we preach! D.N.I.S. becomes W.C.A.G. 2.0 compliant
- Scheme for Incentives to the Private Sector a total flop admits P.M.
- Online C.A.T. 2009 “environment friendly” but not disabled friendly
- Supreme Court judgement out on Right to Motherhood of mentally retarded
- Banks sit on 10,000 crores meant for disability
- High Court directs Centre to reconsider discriminatory insurance rules
- Second Conference of States Parties to U.N.C.R.P.D. held in New York
- Asia’s first centre for higher education for disabled people started in U.P.
- Supreme Court asks government to fill up job vacancies for disabled persons
- Cochlear launches implantable hearing solutions in India
Disability News and Information Service is produced and managed by: